Can South Dakota Write Math and English Standards for South Dakota?

The Thomas B Fordham Institute has been widely recognized as giving the Common Core State Standards Fordham 98 2000 2005 math standards grade a grade that the standards can’t possibly support. They have been widely criticized for accepting $1 million from the Gates Foundation to promote the Common Core Standards. (Link)

But before the Common Core, the Fordham Institute had been grading state education standards since 1996. And that is what I want to focus on today.

It has been said that the Common Core Standards are better than 90% of state education standards in 2010. And while I do not want to debate how the Common Core was graded by Fordham, I do want to talk about the history of South Dakota Standards, and more specifically the grades those standards received.

In 2005, before the Common Core, Fordham released “The State of State Math Standards” by David Klein professor of Mathematics at California State University in Northridge. He is an advocate of increasingly rigorous treatment of mathematics in school curricula and a frequently cited opponent of reforms based on the NCTM standards (Common Core Math). In this report Fordham gave our 2005 standards a “C”. One of the first things Fordham noted was that replacing the standards we had in place in 2000 was a “misstep”. You see, Fordham had given the math standards that were in place in 2000 an “A”. 2005 ELA South Dakota Standards

In 2005, Fordham also released the report “The State of the State English Standards”. In that report, written by Sandra Stotsky, Ed D., who led Massachusetts to number one in the nation on the NAEP, gave South Dakota English standards that were in place in 2005 a “B”.  While there were suggestions on how to improve those standards by adding to the 7-12 literature standards, those standards were a solid “B”.

South Dakota wrote the math standards we had in place in 2000. We could use those. They were an “A”

South Dakota wrote the English language arts standards we had in place in 2005. While there were suggestions on how to improve those standards by adding to the 7-12 literature standards, those standards were a solid “B”. As a matter of fact, we were ranked number 6 in the nation for our English standards.

So when asked, “If we replace the Common Core, what do we replace it with? If we can’t reference other multi state standards, how will we write new standards?”

We can replace the Common Core Standards with top-rate South Dakota standards and keep our 2005 English Honor Roll # 6educational autonomy.

Oh and there are tests that we can use that are not Common Core aligned that can be used for accountability. Tests that have many years of validity and reliability.

State of the State Math Standards 2005

State of the State English Standards 2005

3 thoughts on “Can South Dakota Write Math and English Standards for South Dakota?

  1. Even more, why could we not just adopt the number one standards that Massachusetts had.  There are plenty of better options from which to choose.  Common Core seems to be among the worst of all options.

  2. Jim is correct; however, I would venture that within S.D. we have more than enough talent to devise our own standards thus keeping local control intact. S.D. is unique as is every other state. Students moving through each states unique systems serves to enrich the cultural milieu. Stalin tried the opposite in the 30’s, a top down cookie cutter education system the devastating effects of which are still felt today.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s